Rebecca De Mornay Natalie 'Mother' Koffin Jaime King Beth Sohapi Patrick John Flueger Izaak 'Ike' Koffin Warren Kole Addley Koffin Deborah Ann Woll Lydia Koffin Briana Evigan Annette Langston Shawn Ashmore George Barnum Frank Grillo Daniel Sohapi Kandyse McClure Gina Jackson Lyriq Bent Treshawn Jackson Lisa Marcos Julie Ross Matt O'Leary Jonathan 'Johnny' Koffin Jessie Rusu Melissa McGuire Tony Nappo Dave Lowe Jason Wishnowski Charlie Kaufman A.J. Cook Vicky Rice Alexa PenaVega Jenna Luther J. LaRose Hospital Security Guard