Nicolas Cage John McLoughlin Maria Bello Donna McLoughlin Maggie Gyllenhaal Allison Jimeno Danny Nucci Officer Giraldi Stephen Dorff Scott Strauss Michael Peña Will Jimeno Jay Hernandez Dominick Pezzulo Michael Shannon Dave Karnes Dorothy Lyman Allison's Mother Peter McRobbie Allison's Father Wass Stevens Pat McLoughlin Frank Whaley Chuck Sereika Viola Davis Mother in Hospital with Donna Connor Paolo Steven McLoughlin Armando Riesco Antonio Rodrigues Jon Bernthal Christopher Amoroso Jude Ciccolella Inspector Fields Julie Adams Allison's Grandmother Nick Damici Lieutenant Kassimatis Martin Pfefferkorn Homeless Addict #1 Tawny Cypress Bleeding Woman Brad William Henke Allison's Brother Donna Murphy Judy Jonas Jay Acovone Donna's Male Neighbor William Mapother Marine Sergeant Thomas